A.) I either quit immediately with no remorse. B.) I continue due to the expectation that it will get good later. Or C.) I force myself to finish the season because my form of self-harm is watching things that make me miserable.
If the title didn't give away how I feel about this show, then certainly this intro will.
American Horror Story (AHS) is a show released in the 2010s. I remember this show coming out around the time that I consider to be the beginning of the golden age of television. Television from the late 2000s to early 2010s had sort of a renaissance where almost every show was on the quality level of cinema. I swear from like 2008 to 2011, all of the shows that people foam over came out: Breaking Bad, Community, Parks and Rec, Modern Family, the Middle, BBC Sherlock, The Walking Dead, Game of Thrones, and this show.
I didn't watch it at the time since I was quite squeamish around horror when I was younger. And when I finally stopped being squeamish, I didn't watch AHS purely because I heard the show wasn't worth my time. However, now it is Halloween. This show is still around. And over the years, I've had a few people in my life claim that it is actually worth giving a try. So with that, I will try a sample with the first season of American Horror Story which is colloquially known as the Murder House.
And then, I was thrusted into a Scenario C situation.
To be fair, AHS also has a dash of Scenario B because this show has a lot of elements that theoretically work. You can say, it is a show with a lot of good ideas. The Murder House is about a random white American family that decides to move into a new house after a noted event throws the family into dysfunction. And because this is an American horror story, this new house is rather haunted...and American. And throughout the season, we get to learn about this house, its former inhabitants, and the fate of this family that you probably won't really care about.
If I had to explain why I didn't find Murder House enjoyable down to a sentence, I would say that Murder House fails to makes its characters likeable making the scary elements that affect these characters ineffective, and also the story is bloated with too many characters, and yeah this sentence is starting to become unruly and grammatically incorrect.
Never have I seen a story where practically everyone is so blatantly unlikeable. Almost all the characters either come off as self-interested, annoying, or plain moronic. It bothers the hell out of me because I am watching this thinking "I can see this working." Are these characters just poorly written? Are the actors just not great at portraying the nuances?
No, I think the problem is that 90% of the drama is pure dramatic irony where the characters don't have access to all the information which leads to misunderstandings. Characters are acting horribly towards one another, and it could all be rectified by a simple explanation. It's worse than Romeo and Juliet because at least that story didn't have cell phones or whatnot.
"What's that, the maid looks like an old person to you but a hot seductress to me??? Man, there is something fishy about this place."
Speaking of the maid, can we talk about the social commentary related to her? I know I am jumping around. But fuck it, the show does the same thing, so I am doing it too.
At this point, I will be spoiling the first season of American Horror Story.
There is a layer of social commentary that discusses the sexual objectification of women and how women can be maligned through gaslighting and other abusive means. I admire its intention, but the execution is messy. It feels like there are times where the show is trying to undermine its own message. Moira (Frances Conroy/Alexandra Breckenridge) the maid complains about the gaslighting of men only to gaslight herself when Ben tried to fire her for the first time. I also understand part of Ben's (Dylan McDermott) arc is not to see women as sexual temptations and come to terms with his issues, but his rebuking of Moira earlier on felt like a step forward, and I don't think sexually harassing someone who is going through the death of their child and other marriage issues is helpful, Moira!
I suppose you can say it is the influence of the devil in the house that causes Moira and the other ghosts to misbehave, but that leads to my next thing. How does the house work? I understand they are going for ambiguity but like why? The show is eager to tell the audience practically everything else. We get the backstory of almost every former residence of the Murder House. You are told almost immediately that the people in the Murder House are ghosts when presenting that as a twist would have been better. They randomly establish a spirit medium who you would think would be established to give explanations about the house. But no, she barely has any payoffs throughout the entire season other than one subversion that I will get to later. I understand that horror has a element of ambiguity. However, that ambiguity should leave the viewer with a sense of dread and hopelessness not simple confusion.
I suppose that is a good question to ask when talking about a horror story that happens to be American. How does AHS try to be scary?
Well for one, the show has no shame in being as gratuitous as possible. If you find sexual violence, mass shootings, and people with mental illnesses scary, then AHS will be right for you. As for me, its depictions of such things were more pathetic than scary. Having a character with Down Syndrome isn't scary. I guess I admire their attempt later on to humanize her, but it doesn't really matter since she gets unceremoniously killed off before the season even reaches the halfway point. Having Tate (Evan Peters) being a mass murderer isn't scary, and the whole scene where he shoots up the library feels so out of place. Not that school shootings can't be used for horror, but they have to be more than just a cheap scare. Similar to the depictions of rape, if not handled with care, it can come off as cheap and gratuitous much like everything else in this story. Speaking of rape, there is a ton of it. Second question, do you want to be scared while also feeling the sensation of sexual arousal while doing it? Well come on down to AHS where the rape is half off for every purchase of a pointless jump scare or shot of gore.
"God, I am exhausted. I am so regretting doing this review. Why did I decide to waste my Halloween on this? I could be watching the X-Files this year!!!!"
...Sorry I'm venting.
What do I like about this show? After all, I did establish AHS having good elements. And to extend on that, the Murder House has some legitimately good things in them. The acting is great. I particularly like the main cast, specifically Connie Britton, Taissa Farmiga, and McDermott.
There are a few instances where the casting is retroactively silly. For example, it is hard to see Matt Ross as a mad doctor without first seeing Gavin Belson from Silicon Valley. Likewise, the scenes where Kate Mara is stabbing people, which is already hilarious due to how many times she does it, was made even more funny by me thinking of Invisible Woman getting a little too frustrated by her circumstances.
I really like the theme song. It is one of those intros that you don't want to skip. I like some of the visuals and neat horror ideas like Moira looking different to certain people. I liked when the girl ate the cupcake. I wish I could expand on that, but all I have on my notes related to that scene was "cupcake scene was cool." I guess that is on me for taking crappy notes.
The major twist where the daughter, Violet (Taissa Farmiga), was actually dead for most of the season was actually pretty lit. Although, I don't know if the effectiveness was from the twist being well crafted or if the show was so just so unenjoyable that it put me in a false sense of security setting me up to get caught off guard. I actually was starting to like the two episodes preceding the finale. Because after the twist, the show shifts gears to focusing on things that were actually a mystery. How to stop the house? Why are the spirits trapped? They stopped dwelling on the pointless dramatic irony and instead focused on things that were actually interesting. For a moment, I thought this show might be a Scenario B type show after all.
But then, you get the actual ending.
In summary, Vivian (Connie Britton) has twins. One of them dies and the other becomes as psychotic as Tate (who btw raped Vivian, whoops!). Vivian dies during childbirth. Ben gets killed so quickly that it felt like they were trying to be a subversive in how anticlimactic it was. However, it doesn't work since they already did that when Violet tries to destroy a ghost after listening to some advice from a spirit medium. And just when you think it is going to work, it turns out it doesn't. I'm glad they like that subversion so much they tried to shoehorn it into another scene where it clearly wouldn't have worked as well.
The season ends where everyone is dead. But hey, at least the family is together. It's happy isn't it? It would have been better if Ben and Vivian "I don't know" divorced like they should have. It would have been messy, but it wouldn't have ended with being stuck in a house with ghosts who don't know how to resolve their mental health issues.
The final episode really highlights just how bloated this season was. There are so many characters it tries to resolve in this one episode. I wonder how much better this show would have been if a few of them were cut out. The gay couple is really only there to establish why the house has a gimp suit and to add a bit more conflict near the end. There could have been another way to throw in a gimp suit that didn't involve casting two people and developing backstories for each of them. The twins didn't need to be there other than for a few visual scenes. The female actor had very little purpose either. Why bother dedicating screen time to characters that have very little impact on the story?
The number of episodes feel the same way. If I was feeling generous, I can see this season work with nine episodes, and it would have been paced a lot better. And honestly, Murder House certainly feels like a four episode mini series stretch out to 12.
Oh yeah, I guess I should mention that the AHS also ends with Ben going on an anti-therapy tirade that is one of the most misinformed pieces of writing ever. I won't go too much into it since this review is long enough, and this scene could easily be expanded into a blog of its own. But in short, no, therapy isn't some place where folks can wave off responsibility. It's actually the opposite. No, therapy isn't a place where people can claim their unaccountable for their actions by blaming their mothers. No, therapy can work, and whoever wrote this terrible monologue should be ashamed of themselves.
It doesn't help that the monologue also gives Tate a very unsatisfactory sense of closure. Like everything else in this show, it ends with a whimper. It's not scary. It's frustrating.
And people say the later seasons are worse? Oh God....
So that is Murder House. In ways, with how this show went, it makes me a tad curious for how the other seasons turned out. As bad as this season was, it gave me so much to talk about. That said, I should not let morbid curiosity make me forget about the fact that this show is a Scenario C, and that I need to send a few stern text messages to the handful of people who recommended this show to me.
So for now, I will avoid AHS. I'm glad I finally got this show off my list and can pass on to greener pastures.
Oh, and of course, Happy Halloween.






